As the automotive industry moves towards a more sustainable future, demand for electric vehicles (EVs) is on the rise. A critical part of these vehicles is their electric motors. This article will explore the different types of electric motors used in electric vehicles, how they work, and their advantages and disadvantages.
Alternating Current (AC) Induction Motor
How it works: This type of motor was invented by Nikola Tesla in the 19th century. The AC induction motor works by creating a magnetic field in the rotor of the motor through current induction. This means that it does not need direct connections to turn the rotor, unlike other types of motors.
Advantages and disadvantages of the AC induction motor
Advantages: AC induction motors are robust and require less maintenance due to the absence of brushes or commutators. They are also very efficient in terms of energy consumption.
Disadvantages: One of the main disadvantages of AC induction motors is that they require an inverter to convert direct current (DC) from the vehicle battery to alternating current (AC). This additional component can increase the cost and complexity of the system.
Direct Current (DC) Permanent Magnet Motors
How it works: DC permanent magnet motors use permanent magnets to create the magnetic field needed to rotate the motor’s rotor. This type of motor converts electrical energy into mechanical energy through the attraction and repulsion of magnetic fields.
Advantages and disadvantages of DC permanent magnets
Advantages: DC permanent magnet motors are more compact and lighter than AC induction motors. They are also very efficient and provide excellent performance at low speeds, making them ideal for electric vehicles.
Disadvantages: DC permanent magnet motors are more expensive to manufacture due to the cost of the rare earth magnets used. In addition, these motors can have overheating problems due to the loss of magnetism of the magnets at high temperatures.
Synchronous Reluctance Motor
Operation: Synchronous reluctance motors operate using magnetic reluctance, i.e. the resistance of a material to a magnetic field. These motors are characterised by having a rotor without a squirrel cage or magnets, which gives them certain advantages.
Advantages and disadvantages of the Synchronous Reluctance Motor
Advantages: Synchronous reluctance motors are less expensive to produce as they do not require rare earth magnets. They are also robust, efficient and offer good performance.
Disadvantages: One of the main disadvantages of synchronous reluctance motors is that, although they are cheaper to produce, their cost is still higher than that of induction motors. In addition, these motors need speed synchronisation with the inverter output frequency, which requires the use of a rotor position sensor and sensorless control. Compared to the induction motor, it is slightly heavier and has a lower power factor. However, by increasing the saliency ratio, i.e. the ratio of direct inductance to quadrature inductance, the power factor can be improved.
Asynchronous Motor (or Induction Motor)
Operation: Asynchronous motors, also known as induction motors, operate on the principle of electromagnetic induction. In these motors, current is induced in the rotor by the magnetic field of the stator, which causes the rotor to rotate. The speed of the rotor is always lower than the speed of the stator magnetic field, hence the term “asynchronous”.
Advantages and disadvantages of the asynchronous motor
Advantages: Asynchronous motors are robust, reliable and require little maintenance due to the absence of brushes and commutators. They are also efficient in terms of energy consumption. In addition, they are cheaper and easier to manufacture compared to other types of motors.
Disadvantages: One disadvantage of asynchronous motors is that their speed depends on the frequency of the supply current, which means that the speed of the motor cannot be precisely controlled without an inverter. In addition, these motors can be less efficient at low speeds compared to other types of motors.
It is important to mention that AC induction motors and asynchronous motors are very similar in terms of operation and characteristics, and sometimes these terms are used interchangeably. However, there are subtle differences between them, mainly in the way the speed of the motor is controlled. In an AC induction motor, the speed is controlled by adjusting the frequency of the current, whereas in an asynchronous motor, the speed depends on the frequency of the supply current and cannot be precisely controlled without an inverter.
The original text of this article has been extracted from this link. Thanks.